ERCOT Is Ahead of the Curve but Spain’s Blackout Offers a Cautionary Tale

Earlier this week, Spain experienced a major blackout that left millions without electricity, triggered by a sudden drop in grid frequency. It’s a technical term, but frequency is essentially the “heartbeat” of the electric grid. In the U.S., it must remain close to 60 Hertz (Hz), and in Europe, 50 Hz. If it drifts too far from that target, the entire system can destabilize, leading to widespread outages.

Why does frequency drop?
Electricity supply and demand must match in real time. If demand increases suddenly or a large generator goes offline, frequency falls. Sharp, rapid drops can trigger automatic shutdowns to prevent equipment damage, resulting in rolling blackouts.

Source: Ready.gov

How is Texas managing the risk?
Texas, through ERCOT, faces similar challenges, particularly given its high reliance on intermittent generation like wind and solar. But ERCOT has made meaningful progress in managing frequency fluctuations:

• New ancillary services such as the Contingency Reserve Service provide fast-acting support during sudden dips.
• Battery storage is expanding quickly, with capacity expected to quadruple by the end of 2025.
• Load flexibility programs allow large users to reduce consumption during emergencies, helping maintain balance.
• Investment in dispatchable generation is underway, although financing and incentive structures remain a hurdle.

Recent legislation threatens progress
Several new laws and proposed bills are creating barriers for the very resources Texas needs to keep the grid stable. Measures like Senate Bill 1284 and House Bill 5066 introduce regulatory burdens on battery projects. Additional proposals such as SB 714, SB 819, HB 1378, and others add further complexity around siting, interconnection, and operation of renewable and battery installations. These policies, often framed as reliability-focused, risk delaying the deployment of flexible resources that enhance reliability.

ERCOT is also considering reforms that would increase interconnection costs for batteries and renewables, making it harder for developers to justify new investments. This kind of uncertainty around long-term policy direction makes it difficult to build the resource mix Texas needs.

Don’t repeat past mistakes
While intermittent resources come with challenges, removing them from the equation is not the answer. Renewable energy and battery storage are vital to grid stability, especially as ERCOT modernizes. Much like eliminating thermal generation after failures during Winter Storm Uri would have been shortsighted, targeting renewables today could undermine progress toward a more resilient grid. Even recent setbacks, such as the offshore wind blade issue in ISO-NE, should be viewed as hurdles to overcome, not reasons to stall innovation.

What this means for energy users in Texas
Texas energy consumers will be directly affected by how this balance is managed:

• Reliability depends on ERCOT’s ability to invest in a well-rounded mix of dispatchable generation, batteries, and fast-responding services.
• Cost will rise if outages, scarcity pricing events, and investment delays become more frequent. Investing now in a flexible grid could help avoid much steeper costs in the future.

Spain’s blackout is a powerful reminder that grid stability requires coordination, investment, and flexibility. Texas can meet the challenge by embracing a broad mix of generation and supporting technologies, not by narrowing the path forward.

For additional information please contact us to schedule a quick call.