Understanding PJM's Capacity Market: A Simplified Overview

PJM's capacity market plays a vital role in ensuring reliable electricity supply across its 13-state region. It incentivizes power generators to commit to being available when demand peaks, helping keep the lights on for millions of people. Recently, though, the market has made headlines due to a significant price spike, leaving many energy users confused. Let’s break it all down.

What is the Capacity Market?

The capacity market ensures that enough electricity generation resources are available to meet future demand, particularly during high-usage periods like summer heat waves or winter freezes. It achieves this through a competitive auction process where power suppliers bid to provide capacity for a future delivery year.

Why the Recent Price Spike?

Capacity prices in PJM have risen sharply in the latest Base Residual Auction (BRA). This is due to several factors:

• Increased Reliability Needs: As demand forecasts rise and grid reliability requirements tighten, PJM needs to procure more capacity.
• Supply Challenges: Some regions are seeing fewer resources available, either due to plant retirements, regulatory hurdles, or limited transmission capacity.
• Market Design: The auction is structured to attract new resources when needed, which can push prices higher in years where the grid faces supply constraints or growing demand.

While these price spikes can be frustrating for end users, they are sometimes necessary to ensure that enough capacity is available to prevent blackouts during high-demand periods.

PJM RTO Capacity Cleared at $269.92/MW-day*

* BGE Zone Cleared at $466.35/MW-day & Dominion South Zone Cleared at $444.26/MW-day

The Base Residual Auction (BRA): Setting the Stage

The BRA is the main event in PJM’s capacity market. Here’s how it works:

1. Objective: Secure enough capacity to meet PJM’s forecasted electricity demand, plus a reserve margin for reliability.
2. Offer Cap:
   • Bids are capped at 1.1 times Net CONE—the estimated cost of building and operating a new resource minus expected energy market revenues.
   • This ensures bids reflect real costs without becoming excessive.
3. Price Settlement: A “single clearing price” mechanism ensures all successful participants receive the same price, determined by the intersection of supply (bids) and demand (PJM’s reliability requirement).

What About Incremental Auctions?

After the BRA, PJM holds incremental auctions closer to the delivery year to adjust capacity commitments. These auctions help account for updated forecasts or changes in resource availability.

How Do Prices Vary Across Regions?

PJM is divided into different geographic zones, and prices can vary between them due to transmission constraints:

• High-demand areas with limited generation or transmission capacity see higher prices to ensure reliability.
• Low-demand areas or those with excess capacity see lower prices.

This separation ensures each zone secures the capacity it needs to meet its local reliability requirements.

Why Do Capacity Prices Fluctuate So Much?

Capacity prices can vary significantly from year to year based on:

• Changes in Demand: Economic growth, electrification, or extreme weather forecasts can drive up demand projections.
• Supply-Side Dynamics: Retirements of older plants, delayed new projects, or fuel supply challenges can tighten the market.
• Policy and Regulation: New market rules or environmental standards can affect resource availability.

While the recent price spike is unusual, these fluctuations are inherent to a market designed to adapt to changing grid conditions.

Why Are High Prices Sometimes Necessary?

In years where the market signals a need for new resources or additional reliability, prices rise to attract investment. Without this, PJM could face reliability risks, such as blackouts or energy shortages during peak periods. Though it’s frustrating for energy users, these higher prices ensure long-term stability.

What’s the Takeaway?

PJM’s capacity market is a forward-looking system designed to match supply with demand while balancing cost efficiency and reliability. The recent price spike underscores the market’s role in signaling when more resources are needed to ensure the grid remains reliable.

For energy users, understanding these dynamics can provide clarity—and highlight the importance of proactive energy management strategies to mitigate cost impacts.

For additional information please contact us to schedule a quick call.